As NFL training camps approach and teams finalize their rosters for the 2025 campaign, a blistering new list from Bleacher Report has sent shockwaves through the Packers fanbase. Two Green Bay stars have been named among the most overpaid players in the entire NFL heading into the season—and it’s already stirring major controversy.
The first name? Star cornerback Jaire Alexander.
Yes, the same Jaire Alexander who, when healthy, is often regarded as a top-5 cornerback in the NFL. But health is exactly the problem—and the critics are not being kind. Alexander is entering the 2025 season on the heels of two injury-riddled years and carries a cap hit north of $24 million. For a player who missed significant time last season and had tension with the coaching staff, many are questioning if the Packers are getting an elite return on their investment.
Alexander’s talent is undeniable, but his availability and consistency have come under fire. One anonymous NFC scout put it bluntly: “He has all the tools, but if you’re paying him to be the guy who locks down WR1s every week, then you better hope he’s on the field. And that hasn’t been the case.”
And the second name? Quarterback Jordan Love.
Despite leading the Packers to the playoffs in 2024 and showing promise as Aaron Rodgers’ successor, Love’s inclusion on the list shocked many. However, the reasoning centers around his recent contract extension—a four-year deal worth up to $185 million, including $95 million guaranteed. Critics say the deal was premature, noting that Love has only one full season as a starter under his belt and still showed signs of inexperience and erratic decision-making.
Pro Football Focus graded Love as the 16th-best quarterback last season—middle of the pack. While his trajectory is undeniably upward, the idea of paying him like a top-five QB is what has drawn ire from analysts. The Packers are betting big on his development, but if he regresses or plateaus, it could become one of the costliest gambles in franchise history.
Still, the Packers brass stands by both players. Head coach Matt LaFleur praised Alexander’s effort and leadership during minicamp, stating, “Jaire is a cornerstone of this defense. What he brings—on and off the field—is irreplaceable.” Meanwhile, GM Brian Gutekunst reaffirmed their belief in Love, saying, “Jordan earned everything last year. We believe in him. He’s just getting started.”
Despite the criticism, both players are set to play pivotal roles in Green Bay’s 2025 season. But the pressure is on. With massive contracts comes massive expectations—and the margin for error has evaporated.
If Alexander and Love perform up to their potential, the Packers will be in the NFC Championship conversation. If they don’t? These contracts could haunt the franchise for years to come.
Packers Nation is holding its breath.