In the aftermath of the loss, attention has turned to a key moment during the second goal. As Enock Agyei found space to strike, McCowan was nearby but slow to react. Positioned just outside the box, he failed to close down the shot in time, allowing the opportunity to unfold too easily. It was a moment that summed up Celtic’s lack of urgency on the day.
Pundit Kris Boyd was quick to highlight the incident during post-match analysis, questioning McCowan’s approach in that situation. He pointed out the midfielder’s body language as he moved to engage, suggesting it lacked the decisiveness required at that level.
The criticism didn’t stop there. The wider panel echoed similar concerns, noting that Celtic had enough players back in defensive positions but still failed to apply the basic principles—pressing the ball, closing space, and reacting quickly.
Former professionals on the panel agreed that McCowan needed to be more aggressive in shutting down the shot, with the general consensus being that the goal could have been prevented with sharper decision-making.
For McCowan, the moment carries added weight. As someone who understands the expectations at Celtic, performances like this are always going to be closely examined. Supporters demand intensity and commitment, especially in difficult matches.
It also comes shortly after confident remarks in which he suggested no team in the league could match Celtic at their best. In light of recent performances, those comments have drawn renewed attention.
This season was seen as a chance for McCowan to establish himself more firmly within the squad. However, inconsistency has made it difficult for him to build momentum, and displays like the one at Tannadice have only increased the pressure.
With the title race tightening and little room for error, every detail matters. For players, especially those still trying to cement their place, moments like this can shape perception quickly.
As Celtic look ahead, questions remain about roles, performances, and who can meet the demands required. McCowan’s ability is not in question—but translating that into consistent impact is now the real challenge.